What’s the Difference Between Active, Inactive, and Other Types of Vaccines?

Our clinical staff is often asked by participants whether or not vaccines can cause the infections they’re supposed to prevent. Or, put another way, “Is this a live vaccine?” This has been especially true for our COVID-19, influenza, anthrax, and Zika virus studies.

The answer is almost always no; vaccines generally cannot cause the illnesses they’re intended to prevent.

Vaccines work by exposing you to a small and safe amount of weakened, dead, inactive, or biosynthetic bacteria or viruses. This prompts your immune system to recognize the pathogen and/or defend you from certain diseases.

Sometimes โ€” as in the case of flu vaccines โ€” this can cause mild symptoms, such as a slight fever, soreness around the injection site, and fatigue. In all cases, these minor symptoms are a far better alternative than infection. Mild symptoms can be a sign that your immune system is doing its job effectively.

Live-attenuated vaccines

Live vaccines feature a weakened (or attenuated) form of an infectious agent. ‘Live’ in the term ‘live vaccine’ is a bit of a misnomer. Though viruses play an important role in the tapestry of life, scientists generally do not consider viruses to be alive. Here’s why:

  • Viruses multiply, but they must use host cells to do so.
  • Viruses contain nucleic acid (RNA or DNA), but not cells.
  • Viruses mutate and replicate, but they don’t grow.

Examples of active/live vaccines: Measles/mumps/rubella (MMR); chickenpox; shingles, smallpox.

Inactive or dead vaccines

Inactive, dead, or inert vaccines feature pathogens that cannot multiply, and cannot cause the diseases they’re intended to fight. However, your immune system is still able to recognize and attack these inactive pathogens to build immunity.

Examples of inactive/dead vaccines: Flu (shot), polio, rabies, whooping cough (pertussis)

Conjugate or subunit vaccines

These biosynthetic vaccines only contain fragments of the pathogen. This helps the immune system develop a response to a specific piece of a pathogen.

Examples of conjugate and subunit vaccines: Human papillomavirus (HPV), pneumococcal disease, meningococcal disease

DNA and mRNA vaccines

These vaccines are intended to give our cells genetic instructions to create inert pieces of viruses. Our immune system can then recognize and target these pieces to build immunity.

There currently are no approved DNA or mRNA vaccines, though many are being studied in clinical trials.

Viral vector vaccines

These vaccines use harmless viruses to deliver genetic instructions (DNA) to cells and prompt an immune response.

Examples of viral vector vaccines: Hepatitis B, Ebola

Toxoids

Though uncommon, these vaccines help your immune system fight the effects of toxins โ€” not the actual infection.

Examples of toxoid vaccines: Tetanus, diphtheria


Further reading: